Struggling to Be Authentic

September 6, 2015

Categories: Authenticity

Authenticity isn’t easy. I spend a lot of energy trying to project an image I believe people will accept or approve of. On the outside, I try to show what I think people want to see—someone who is confident, smart, laid-back, athletic, etc.

On the other hand, I try to hide the parts of myself I don’t like or view as less acceptable—the parts of myself that I don’t view as ‘cool.’ I try not to show the parts of myself I judge to be nerdy, weak, anxious, or insecure.

Maybe you’re the same way. What parts of yourself do you present to the world? You can think of these characteristics as your ‘public self.’ On the other hand, what parts of yourself do you hide and keep to yourself? You can think of these characteristics as your ‘private self.’

I think it’s probably impossible to get to the point where your public self and private self overlap completely. There will probably always be some disconnect between the two. But as I grow older, I’m trying to get my public self and private self to be as congruent as possible. Here’s why:

  1. Having a big difference between my private and public self is exhausting. If there is a big difference between my inner self, and the self I present to the world, I’m always self-monitoring and editing my inner self in order to portray what I want to the world. This can be exhausting.
  2. Having a big difference between my private and public self makes intimacy difficult. I think we all long for intimacy—which happens when you deeply know another person and are deeply known by another person. But when I am projecting something different than my inner self to the world, the people I develop relationships with are just getting to know my projection—rather than the true me. Plus, if I hide the parts of myself that I’m less proud of, I won’t ever be accepted for who I truly am. Other people might accept the projection, but in the back of my mind I’m not sure if they would accept the real me.

I think being authentic is difficult because it involves a lot of risk. If we present who we really are to the world, without editing, there’s a chance we could be rejected. That’s a pretty awful feeling—to put your cards on the table and then be told that you aren’t enough. But my sense is that the reward—being able to rest in who you really are and experience true intimacy—is worth the risk.

Discussion: How close are your private and public selves? How has projecting an image to the world hurt your ability to experience intimacy? What do you think about the risks of presenting who you really are to the world?


Related Thoughts

No Comments

  1. Jen September 14, 2015 at 1:34 pm - Reply

    I sort of knew this about myself, that there’s a version of myself that I bring to work and a different version that I bring to my friends and family at home. And they are not that far apart, I’m happy to say but, then there’s this third part of me. It’s not a different version but it’s the parts of me that I only share with God. I know them and God knows them. And that has been fine until recently. Because the word you use, intimacy, is both scary and true for me. I find it very difficult to let people in on such an intimate level. I’ve gotten better at it over the summer, sharing with a few select friends my fears, doubts and less “attractive” sides of my personality. But I’ve never actively had to work on showing the whole me because I haven’t had a relationship with anyone where this has been an issue.

    Let me try to make it a bit clearer, I have chosen not to pursue romantic relationships when I’ve known that there would be no future, no happily ever after, as I don’t believe that that is God’s intent. And thus I’ve avoided having to share intimacy with people for a long time. Which has now given me a fear of sharing it instead and like you wrote, maybe it is a fear of being rejected.

    I have to get over my fear of intimacy and work on letting someone in, other than God. And that scares me! But I can also look back at that and realize that maybe this is God’s way of letting me know that I’m finally getting ready for that next step in building relationships with people. If you have any recommendation for any readings that might help, let me know!

  2. Joshua Hook September 20, 2015 at 1:22 pm - Reply

    Thanks for sharing! Intimacy and being okay with showing others our true selves is tough stuff. (And it’s something I struggle with and am working on myself.) One book I read recently that I really liked on this issue was Scary Close by Donald Miller (

Leave A Comment

Subscribe To My Newsletter

Join my mailing list to receive the latest blog posts.

Receive my e-book “The Mental Health Toolkit” for free when you subscribe.